Saturday, August 16, 2008

Dog Parables, Part XI: Do Not Go Gentle




As anyone who has animals probably knows, when they are seriously hurt or ill, their instincts tell them to withdraw and be alone. I'm not sure why that is--perhaps a mechanism designed not to endanger the pack by slowing it down? For whatever reason, on the two days that Smokey was feeling the most pain, he didn't want to be with us. Both times, I found him hiding in a dark, empty bathroom. To a human owner, this behavior can sometimes feel like rejection, but it really isn't. When Smokey withdrew from us, I had to tell myself not to take it personally.

When humans do the same thing, it's much harder to accept. My oldest brother was 16 years older than me, and even though the age difference kept us from being very close, we did have a special bond. The day Mom was scheduled to have me by cesarian section, Carl called home from the high school between classes. He couldn't wait to find out whether he had a little sister at last. Seven years later, he named his daughter for me.

One afternoon in June 2000, I received an emergency phone call at work. My brother had gone into shock because of a ruptured abdominal aneurysm, and he was being transported to a hospital in Urbana. Surgeons operated on him to repair his aorta, but he had a very rough week in ICU. He was delirious, and no one could figure out why.

After he was released from the hospital, he also had a difficult recovery. The doctors restricted his activities to give him time to heal and told him to give up smoking. (If you are a male over the age of 50, smoking greatly increases your risk of abdominal aneurysm. So does high blood pressure. So does family history. This condition is rampant in my family--one aunt, four uncles, and my brother. Only one uncle has survived it, and he is still struggling with complications.)

Carl was unable to quit smoking. And as soon as the doctors gave him permission to drive, he overdid it by driving all the way to Oklahoma to see my niece because they had been estranged.

In December of that year, he got up out of his easy chair one Sunday night and felt a sharp pain in his abdomen. When he spoke to our mom the next day, he promised to go see a doctor if he didn't feel better by Friday.

Carl bled to death that Wednesday night. He was only 58. When they found him, he was near a table where he'd been organizing his money and personal papers. We think he knew he was dying and just gave up rather than go through another surgery.

For a long time, I was very angry with him. He chose to leave us and didn't even bother to tell us good-bye. After a time, I came to understand that as someone looking at his life from the outside, I have no way of knowing how difficult a struggle recovery might have appeared to him. I have no way of guessing how weary he might have felt.

So this parable is one that has a two-pronged moral. If you are facing serious illness and pain, I encourage you to keep on fighting, both for yourself and for the people you love. They'll miss you if you go.

But for those of us who have lost loved ones and feel angry at choices they made--whether to give up the fight or withdraw from relationship--maybe it's time to let go of the anger and replace it with compassion. We'll never know what went on in that other person's heart.

Oh, and if you are over the age of 50 and either smoke or have high blood pressure, please ask your doctor if your abdominal aorta can be screened. It's completely painless; I've had it done even though my risk factors are low. Having this checked can definitely save your life.

I'd like to leave you with my favorite Dylan Thomas poem "Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night," but it's still under copyright. However, you can go here and either read it or hear Dylan Thomas himself recite it by clicking on "Play." You won't be sorry.

25 comments:

AnneDroid said...

What a touching story about your brother. You're so right that from the outside looking in we just don't know what someone sick is feeling. And if they want to be alone what can we do... I guess the walk into the night that Dylan Thomas talks about can only be done alone anyway, whether the family are at the bedside or not.

A lady in our church took her own life last Christmas and it was a terrible shock because nobody had even guessed that she was distressed.

In our house, on the other hand, when one of us is ill, thankfully thus far with fairly trivial condiitons, we all like everyone else to know about it and give us lots of sympathy!!

Trish said...

Ruth:

What a sad but special story you related on this post....your brother must have loved you very much and what honor to have a niece named after you.

You are right, we all suffer pain in our own separate ways...I sure have learned that of late. Some totally withdraw...some need to discuss and share at length.

Good words today Ruth. Thanks as well for your continued support...you are a 'brick' as they say in jolly ol'.....

rhymeswithplague said...

Thank you for sharing your brother's story with us. Good words from you, as usual, that inspire and instruct your readers.

I am just enough of a literary geek to know that Dylan Thomas's poem, one of my favorites also, is a villanelle. I have written haiku, but I have never attempted a villanelle. I will never hear or read that particular poem again without thinking of your brother Carl.

Grandmère Mimi said...

Ruth, what a beautiful reflection. My brother-in-law had surgery for an abdominal aneurysm several years ago. He could not stop smoking. At least he gets screened.

What a lovely story of your healing.

bonnie said...

Dearest Ruth, that was so moving. Thank you so much. You write so beautifully. I am learning compassion through way too much experience lately, but I always remind myself that if I were truly in that person's shoes and could feel their life I would do exactly the same thing.

Christy said...

Oh, Ruth! I'm so sorry!

I love your balance, your mixture of acceptance and resistance.

People feel compelled to do so many things in life we feel are inexplicable. I've done MANY myself, and tried to think and think, WHY???

Yet I know myself to be a smart, good, kind person.

I try to remember that when people seem careless or self-destructive.

I see my teens make repetitive mistakes and I try to gently say--just like you did with us and the screening/smoking warnings in the post--"think, be careful, I'm here for you".

Because in the end, you simply can't control anyone and have to just be a soft place to land.

It's the bittersweetness of life.

Ruth Hull Chatlien said...

Anne, I'm sorry about the suicide. That is always such a shock.

Bob, I'm not sure I'd call you any kind of geek. You're much too "with it" for that.

Mimi, smoking is such a terrible addiction. That's something else I've had to learn not to judge--people who can't quit. My other brother has had great success though with a new medication. Wish I could remember the name of it, but you know how these drug names are. Like something out of a sci fi movie.

Bonnie, I know you've had so many losses yourself lately. Afterward can be such a sobering time.

Christy, I love the phrase "mixture of acceptance and resistance." I hear the yoga teacher in you when you say that, and it makes me want to get back to doing a little bit of yoga. I also agree about not controlling and trying to be a soft place to land.

thailandchani said...

You've hit on a key point. Compassion. In April 2007, I was brought face to face with this after my father killed himself. Somewhere in all of that, I came to realize that we are all on our own path. Having compassion for the path of another is the truest form of redemption.

~*

Bob Brague said...

An afterthought: Both of my parents smoked heavily, back in the days when all the movie stars smoked in the movies. My mother had a mastectomy at age 39, recovered, and then died of "abdominal cancer" at age 47. It wasn't lung cancer. My dad died of pancreatic cancer at age 60. It wasn't lung cancer either. But I have always felt that their smoking must have been a major factor in the cancers that caused both deaths. I am truly sorry to learn about what your brother went through, but I'm glad that he and your niece were no longer estranged.

Sis said...

Ruth - hugs and kisses to you.

I love that poem. I read it when I was in my early twenties and it slammed into me greatly.
XOXO

Jay said...

Ruth, I'm so sorry to hear about your brother. I lost my elder brother young, too, at age 44, from virus pneumonia. You'd think he'd have known he was ill, but he said not a word, not even to his wife. He just came home from school one day (he was a teacher) and said he'd take a nap before dinner .. and never woke.

Hugs to you - I hope Smokey is feeling better soon.

Ruth Hull Chatlien said...

Bob, I wouldn't be at all surprised.

Thanks for the hugs, Sis.

Jay, I'm sorry to learn of your brother's death. He was very, very young to die.

Smokey is seeming more his normal self. We're still trying to keep him quiet though.

Ruth Hull Chatlien said...

Oh, and welcome thailandchani. Thank you for visiting.

grace said...

Wow... a very moving post. I'm really sorry your brother died, and so badly. And thank you, for the inspiration. Please give Smokey another stroke from me...

Border Explorer said...

This brought tears. Thank you for sharing this important piece of your life.

FranIAm said...

I am weeping for so many reasons, not the least of which is that my husband smokes.

Your words go far, wide and deep and you bring us so much wisdom Ruth. I am ever moved by your generosity of spirit in this blog and your consistency of sharing so much with us so beautifully.

Thank you.

it's margaret said...

Dearest Ruth --God bless you. Thank you for this reflection and story.

And the first Christmas of our marriage --we were so poor we could not do gifts.... but my beloved wrapped a little piece of paper up and gave it to me. On that piece of paper, he wrote "I give you my smoking." And he did. He has been smoke free for 26 years now.

thank you again --many blessings.

Tara said...

Ruth, this is such a timely post for me. Thank you. I have been dealing with chronic "mystery" pain for a few years. It's gotten bad enough that I will be having a laproscopy in a few weeks so the doctor can see what's going on. As you might imagine, I have been having all sorts of emotions. Your words are really calming me down. I imagine I'll read this a few more times in the coming days.

Lauralew said...

Thank you for this post, Ruth. Many of the families of my hospice patients are having a tough time with the compassion part. We cannot walk in another's shoes, so we really do not know what we would do in another's situation. We can love, however.

fiwa said...

Ruth! I never put two and two together! I remember you from GardenWeb now. How funny - that so many of us are reconnecting through blogging. Thank you for coming over to visit and letting me know - I would never have made the connection unless you'd told me.

I'm so glad to find someone else who is into meditation. I'm really new to it, so it would be nice to have someone to chat about it with on occassion.

What a sad story about your brother. I have a feeling I will be facing something very similar with a family member soon. It helps to get your perspective on it.

mucho love -
fiwa

dlyn said...

So sorry you lost your bother that way. I worry about all 3 of mine for various reasons. Blessings on your weekend Ruth!

odd chick said...

spoken as someone who has worked through a lot of pain herself- you were able to give honor to your brother by helping others to learn from his life and his pain, and I hear the serenity prayer, and I hear the love and loss and acceptance from your own heart

afeatheradrift said...

Oh Ruth, such a touching story. Thank you so much. It is hard to know what another is going through. At some point we all realize that no matter how close we are to another, they cannot get inside our skin and feel as we do. No words can convey everything. We do our best, and we hope in Christ for the courage and strength to persist in living. It can reach a point I believe that we cannot handle, and thus compassion is the right response to another's choice that might not be our own. I'll run the link. Thanks for such preciously lovely words of wisdom as always.

jenniferw said...

I love that poem. I am so sorry about your brother, Ruth.

Mauigirl said...

So sorry about the loss of your brother.

I love the Dylan poem and have always felt that way - I personally have no intention of going gentle. My husband, however, is much more laissez-faire about medical issues. He refuses to have a colonoscopy, for instance. Maybe it's a man thing. At first I used to get very angry at him for refusing to do what seems like a no-brainer of a test (people who have colonoscopies actually have a lower rate of colon cancer because removing polyps before they become cancerous actually prevents the cancer from ever happening). But now I'm trying not to nag him incessantly about it because it just causes strife. I guess sometimes we have to accept how others react to medical issues and not count on changing them.