Wednesday, August 6, 2008

In Memory of Solzhenitsyn


Alexander Sozhenitsyn died on Sunday. I never attempted to read The Gulag Archipelago, but I did read two of his other works: First Circle and One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovitch. Yet neither of these books, affecting as they are, made as strong an impact on me as one single sentence.

Some thirty years ago, I was sitting in my assigned seat in the chapel at Wheaton College when our speaker for the day quoted Solzhenitsyn. I don't remember the identity of the speaker or the subject of the sermon, but I've never forgotten the statement. It is a quotation from Part II of The Gulag Archipelago:
Gradually it was disclosed to me that the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either—but right through every human heart—and then all human hearts.
The profound truth in that sentence embedded itself in my very soul and has remained there ever since.

Human beings are capable of great good and great evil, and sometimes both extremes can be found in a single individual. 

Even when we're talking about relatively ordinary people, the statement is still true. Each of us is capable of extraordinary generosity and almost unforgivable damage. And unless we recognize both the dark and light within ourselves, we are too apt to judge others, to demonize them as the evil one.

One thing that has helped me to understand the duality that lives within each of us is to recognize that my strengths and my weaknesses, my triumphs and my failings, all come from the same place. I'm not compartmentalized into the good Ruth and her evil twin. All of my actions are the outworking of my one and only self.

Let me give a couple of examples. I am a very verbal person. This means I can be articulate and expressive. I can explain things with clarity. It also means that unless I'm careful, I can dominate conversations or meetings. And when I was a teenager, I sometimes used my verbal ability to dole out scathing putdowns.

I'm sensitive and in tune with my emotions. The positive side to this is feeling empathy for other people and writing believable characters in my fiction. The negative side is having a thin skin when I am slighted or ignored. Sometimes I make the mistake of assuming that "it's all about me."

Do you see what I mean? In each case my strength has the potential to be misused and become a characteristic weakness.

Imagine the same thing on a grander scale. People with great leadership abilities have the temptation of abusing their power. Passionate, charismatic individuals may become adulterers. And so on and so on . . . 

What I like about this way of viewing human nature is that when I become aware of a flaw, I don't have to despise myself. Instead, I simply have to find a way, with God's help, to use that trait more constructively.

The line separating good from evil passes through each and every human heart. But thanks be to God, he wants to redeem us in every way possible.





21 comments:

Bob Brague (rhymeswithplague) said...

Another great post and a great quote from Solzhenitsyn. I love the heart at the end of the post.

But I'm not sure I can agree that, say, a murderer or a child molester can learn to use that trait more constructively. I'll have to think about that one. Maybe there are times when one *should* (even *needs to*) despise oneself (even if one isn't a Calvinist) so that the shock of seeing oneself as one really is, warts and all, turn one toward God and his redemption.

Perhaps I'm coming at the same thing as you are, only from a different direction. As a longtime reader of Flannery O'Connor, I think those moments of grace in her work always come as a shock. Her characters were not usually trying to find a way to use their traits more constructively; they were shocked (at least the readers are) by a recognition of how God's help sometimes manifests itself.

Once again I have gone on for too long in a comment.

I still admire your post. Personal choice is certainly a part of the problem and a part of the solution (to quote Eldridge Cleaver).

Ruth Hull Chatlien said...

I'm think what I'm saying is that for most people, having a more balanced view of the human personality will help keep them for developing those extremes. Certainly, there are some people who are so damaged early on that they need professional help to avoid inflicting more great hurt. But really, there are very few Hitlers and Jeffrey Dahmers and Idi Amins in the world, and this post really isn't directed at them. For most of us, turning toward the good or turning toward the evil is something we choose to do every day, hour after hour.

Ruth Hull Chatlien said...

P.S. Of course no one can learn to use murder or rape more constructively. But we can learn to use anger constructively, can't we?

Sis said...

This is such a thought provoking post, Ruth.

I thank Jesus Christ that the more I empty myself of me, and fill myself with Him, the choices I have to make become more and more clear - maybe not easier, sometimes, but definitely clearer to my eyes as I put on my "new self".

Bob Brague (rhymeswithplague) said...

I agree about anger. St. Paul (I think) said, "Be angry, and sin not." And also, "Don't let the sun go down upon your wrath." So anger and sin are not synonymous, and anger can even be a catalyst to get us moving. We need to get angry enough and upset enough about certain things in our society or town or family to speak or write against them and see wrongs corrected. That would be an example of using anger constructively, I think. But too many times we keep our thoughts to ourselves and nothing is changed.

Joan said...

I only read Ivan Denisovitch, Ruth. That is a great quote. I have read with interest of Solhenitsyn's passing.

I love thinking about redemption and of course, the only solution to anything is forgiveness. If God in great mercy can forgive the worst parts of us, then we are taught to forgive others and equally, ourselves. "If Grace Is True, God Will Save EVERY Person" (Phillip Gulley) not just some of us.

Our character is always two sides of the same coin and it takes maturity to use our self for good...genuinely, humbly, reverently.

Even Hitler is God's child...as despicable as that seems to most of us. How God can redeem souls for eternity is way beyond our human compassion and understanding.
But thanks be to God...who wants us all.

oxoxoxoxo

Dawn said...

I love that quote. It reminds me of when I was studying the book of Romans and Paul was making the point that we ALL have sin and fall short without Christ. Even people who appear to be very good people have that line in their heart and are capable of great evil.

dlyn said...

I was saddened that Alexander Solzhenitsyn has passed away, but I believe we will see him someday, yes?

An interesting turn of events - Christinity Today had asked Chuck Colson to do an article on Solzhenitsyn for the August issue: http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2008/august/18.64.html

I think I will reread The Gulag Archipelago in remembrance...

Bob Brague (rhymeswithplague) said...

I couldn't disagree more with Joan's comment. Philip Gulley may say, "If grace is true, God will save every person," but St. John, the Beloved Disciple, quotes Jesus as having said, "Marvel not at this: the hour is coming, in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice, and shall come forth; they that have done good, unto the resurrection of life; and they that have done evil; unto the resurrection of damnation." (John 5)

So the New Testament indeed teaches that all shall be resurrected, but not that all will be saved in the sense Joan means.

She has confused being God's creation with being God's child. As a descendant of German Jews, I don't think Hitler just needed to be a little more mature child of God. Again, if I turn to the New Testament, I read in Galatians 3: "For ye are all children of God by faith in Christ Jesus. For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ" and it goes on to say "and if ye be Christ's, then are ye Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise."

You can choose to believe the New Testament or you can choose to believe Phillip Gulley . Of course, whosoever [you or me or Hitler or anybody else] calls upon the name of the Lord [even with their last breath], shall be saved (Acts 2).

There is such a thing as free will. God has voted for you; Satan has voted against you. You have the deciding vote. That is a bit different from saying if grace is true, God will save every person.

One view is truth; one view is sentimentality. Or so it seems to me. Jesus didn't come so everybody could feel good about himself, He came to save sinners.

Sharon said...

What a great quote. I can see why it left such an impact on you. It is so true, we all have both good and bad in us. I am so thankful to the Lord for His mercy and grace!

Hugs, Sharon

Jay said...

A very good post. I love the Solzhenitsyn quote, too. It's absolutely spot on. I haven't actually read any Solzhenitsyn, but maybe I should.

You have an award waiting for you over at my place. :)

Diane Vogel Ferri said...

Once again, Ruth , a thought-provoking post. I think you should gather all these post and put them into a book.

grace said...

He was an amazing man...

Sherry Peyton said...

Terrific post Ruth. I agree in large part. I do think we all have both aspects of most characteristics within us. We are always attempting, we hope, to cultivate the good, and winnow away the bad. Aristotle in his Ethics alludes to this in some ways by suggesting the good man is the lives in the mean--not too generous, not too stingy, not gluttonous but not starving himself.

Everyone is trying to do what they perceive is the best for themselves. Obviously what some see as good for themselves is far from what I would, objectively or subjectively. But we are all in the struggle together it seems, and I suspect that which we judge worst in others is that which we fear most in ourselves.

I'm with Joan, while Christianity may indeed in large part teach that sinners aren't saved, I think that may be more of convenience than not. I don't recall Jesus speaking much on this. It would be wonderous to me should God in perfect mystery see that no one is separated permanently from Him.

I always trust that effort is the main issue here. God is pleased with our efforts. In fact, some suggest that God, being Goodness personified is unable to see our evil behavior. I'm not sure about that, but it's an interesting thought.

You certainly know how to get a person thinking! Thanks.

nikkipolani said...

An excellent quote - no wonder it left its mark on you. I'd read Ivan Denisovitch long long ago.

Joan said...

I carefully read your comment, Bob. And I meant no disrespect to you or your beliefs...you have valid beliefs. I can only share my own heart and experience and have come to know that only forgiveness will give the world Peace.

That is all I meant, Bob.
Blessings to you...
J.

rhymeswithplague said...

Joan, thank you for responding so kindly. I meant no disrespect to you, either, though it may have seemed that way.

You are right, God can and does forgive the worst parts of us, as you wrote in your first comment, but the point I was trying to make was this: only if we repent (which means to change our minds, to turn from the direction we are going and go in another direction, God's direction). And the only way to remain sane is to forgive ourselves and others.

jenniferw said...

Solzhenitsyn was a great man and I was saddened to hear of his death.

One of the most profound truths about human beings is the fact you point out: our greatest strength and our greatest weakness is often one and the same. Only the miracle of being "transformed by the renewing of your mind, that ye may prove what is that good, and acceptable, and perfect, will of God" can make the life profitable in any eternal sense. Thank God that He is "longsuffering to us-ward ..."

"JEANNELLE" said...

Ruth,

This post just bulges with wisdom.....I agree with another comment-maker......you could build a book from this post!

Stratoz said...

interesting thoughts here. I heard an NPR story soon after he died which showed both the good and bad of the man himself. we are all imperfect, that is a given.

Wormwood's Doxy said...

Bob---from the cross, Jesus said "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do."

I believe God did just that----despite the fact that the people who murdered Jesus were NOT repentant.

Universalism is an old and honored tradition in Christianity. Those of us who adhere to it do so based on Jesus' last act---unasked-for absolution, and pardon without repentance by the guilty.

You can say things like "You can believe the New Testament" if you like---but many of us do just that. And the words of Jesus from the cross show us the true nature of the God we love and worship. He is not a God of anger and punishment, but One of forgiveness, grace, and mercy.

Pax,
Doxy