I've been thinking more about poverty since Blog Action Day, and I decided to examine the topic from another angle.
As I mentioned last week, I've been having some time off before I start my next writing assignment, and during this time, I've been getting a lot accomplished. I still have a lot that I could do in the garden, but I've cleaned it up enough that I could live with going into the winter this way if I had to. And I'm making progress on my novel revision.
Earlier this year, I had a five-week period of having no work. It was during the months of March and April, so it would have been a great time for me to do some of the basic spring gardening work, but I didn't do it. I didn't do very much on my novel either. What energy I had was devoted to trying to find writing jobs and trying to stretch our budget, and at the end of every day, I was weary from dealing with the stress.
Later in the spring, even after we started getting a string of steady small assignments, I didn't make much effort on either my garden or my novel. During all that time, I continued to have a low level of anxiety about our finances and our job assignments because even though we were working hard, we weren't earning as much as we needed to be. And when a person is scared about basic survival, it's difficult to expend energy on non-essential creative outlets.
Compared to many people, we haven't had that bad a year, and to even relate it to survival fear is an exaggeration. Yet the slow year we've experienced did give me some insight into the emotional cost of economic troubles. For people who have to struggle with poverty every day, life is a constant grind. Multiply my experience by two or three times the amount of anxiety, and the result can be paralyzing.
When you're exhausted and stressed out from trying to pay for the latest medical test or make the mortgage, you don't have enough energy to give your life an economic makeover. You're in survival mode and all you can do is try to keep up with your expenses, not get ahead. That's why it's so hard for people who are in poverty to "pull themselves up by the bootstraps." They're living out a real-life monopoly game in which the moment they pass GO and collect their $200, they land on some property with a hotel and have to fork out more than twice times that amount in rent. When a person doesn't have enough resources to start with, the smallest extra expense can seem like a real catastrophe.
Even if we can't feel compassion for the individuals in that situation, let's look pragmatically at the effect of poverty on society. Twelve percent of the U.S. population is below the poverty line. (That statistic comes from the CIA World Factbook.) That means that one in eight Americans is struggling to get by. And if my own experience is any indication, the stress and worry that come with economic uncertainty can rob people of creativity and initiative.
Can this country really afford to blow off the potential creativity and initiative of 12 percent of its people? Personally, I think we need for everyone to live free from the fear of hunger or bankruptcy due to catastrophic illness. I think "spreading the wealth" and providing health care will help us to have a higher percentage of productive, contributing citizens, and that's why I don't mind hearing politicians propose "socialist" policies (although I would argue that they are using the term incorrectly). I think having a strong safety net is not only good for the individuals involved, it's better for society as a whole too.
19 comments:
Poverty takes its own toll and also paves the way for further personal traumas from which recovery becomes perhaps impossible. Thanks for this wonderful reflection & sharing.
I SO agree--and I get called a commie all the time, and I dont' care at all!!
LOL
ruth, the issues we are facing bring me to my knees.
Oh Ruth this is so true. Poverty is not a family value at all, yet things like LGBT marriage and other social matters are blamed for the collapse of the so-called family.
I think it is more a collapse of humanity - in a giant world of stress and pressure to make money only to send it all back out for bills.
It is like being in some kind of exhausting bucket brigade for so many... they can never extinguish the flames or be free.
Those at the bottom rungs suffer greatly. I have been reflecting on this a my long time unemployed state grows longer and our resources grow shorter.
My poor would be extravagant to many.
Yes, MA'AM. You got to the center of the issue.
Yes, you really did.
I think what you said about poverty leaving little room for creativity and initiative is absolutely correct. Right out of college, my husband and I were struggling financially until we found jobs and it was incredibly draining...I watched a lot of t.v. during that time in my life...I just wanted to "escape".
Yes, poverty is exhausting - haven't most of us been there at one time or another, due to school debts or bad decisions or whatever? It is scary and it is exhausting.
I still haven't written a post, but I will. Right now my health issues are zapping my creativity, but it's still on my mind.
You hit the nail on the head with this post.
Have a happy Wednesday!
Penetrating and thoughtful, as usual, Ruth.
I'm always bemused by the "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" thing. It is physically impossible. In fact, it is physic--ally impossible (as in, against the Laws of Physics). Try it sometime...I did and it was rather enlightening.
Pax,
Doxy
And even if you could pull yourself up by your bootstraps, you'd have to have boots in the first place, and lots of folks don't.
Very well said Ruth, especially about the loss of the creative power of tens of millions of people who cannot afford to devote any time to any pursuit that is not directly related to survival. I am sickened by the lengths McCain and Palin are willing to go to paint Obama as a now a socialist, for doing nothing more than is commonly done by every politician, try to get tax breaks for their constituents. Apparently if you are giving the break to the wealthy, that's good capitalism, if to the middle and working classes, it's socialism. How disgusting.
This is such a great post Ruth. You've really hit on something I've been feeling lately that I never have before, a sort of paralyzing feeling of dread. I've been going back and forth between just letting myself feel it and hoping it will pass quickly, and fighting it.
Like Feather, I am sickened to my core at the tactics Republicans are using. If you haven't seen it, watch The Daily Show from Oct. 14th on the site. Stewart likens it to "building Frankenstein seems really cool until the monster goes berserk." I'm paraphrasing, but you get the idea. There are clips of people shouting horrible things at McCain rallies and McCain looking panicked because he suddenly realizes what he's done.
Oh, I so much want this to be a new and better America. A place where no one will have to deal with the kind of energy-draining situations you describe.
Sure, some will always have more than others, but in this country there needs to some kind of safety net to ensure basic needs can be met by someone who is willing to put in a good day's work. As it stands now, that's not the case.
Hi, Ruth!
Well, I don't know what's right politically. I don't mean to be wishy-washy, but I have a hard time believing, anymore, that if the government gets involved with something it won't turn into a big mess (i.e. post-Katrina). But I heartily agree that when one is in survival mode, it is very difficult to be creative or to think "outside of the box" about anything. It is a grind of putting just putting one foot in front of the other to get by.
More and more people are in terrible straits, these days, and my heart just goes out to them. I hope and pray that someone will make the difference for this nation...We shall see.
God bless,
Elizabeth
Poverty hits us all on so many levels. Good post Ruth!
XOXOXOX
A Nigerian chief once said, "If you don't share your wealth with us, we will share our poverty with you". ... i think that this statement is true.. and also Ruth, I loved the hymn, "I sought the Lord". I wrote the beautiful words in my prayer journal. thank you.
Great post, Ruth. I worked in a social service agency for a decade. We helped families to get off of state assistance, find jobs and affordable day care. It was so hard for people to get ahead the way the system was set up. I learned a lot in that job about poverty and how people struggled, that I would have never known about otherwise. So many women and children at poverty level in such a great country like ours... it isn't right.
Ruth, I so appreciate the depth and vulnerability you show in your writing. Poverty hasn't been given its due in this election. That's why I so like that essay by Joan Chittister about checking out the candidates according to their policies in relation to the poor.
The Monopoly analogy is an excellent one!
Post a Comment